Musing on the demise of Learning Media NZ

Why the ghost of Uncle Russell is on my mind tonight (and how I am trying to honour his memory).



Declarations of personal interests to temper your reactions to this post.

1. I am proud to be an educator in, and advocate for,  the New Zealand State School System, as founded by Beeby (influenced by Dewey)  during the first Labour Government in the late 1930s.


2. Through marriage I am proud of my family relationship with Russell Clark and his work.



As illustrator for the New Zealand Listener and New Zealand School Journal, Russell Clark’s art became part of New Zealanders’ daily lives from the 1940s to 1970s.


Clark attended Canterbury College School of Art, in Christchurch from 1922 to 1928,... It was as a painter and sculptor that Clark contributed to an emerging Modernist movement in Post-War New Zealand.  


In 1944 he was appointed Pacific War Artist by the New Zealand government, and this experience in Polynesia and Melanesia stimulated his inquiry into Māori art and culture, culminating in the Urewera series (1949-1951). Ironically, these works also reveal the influence of British artists Henry Moore and Barabara Hepworth, particularly in the use of stylised monumental forms which in turn were influenced by Pre-Columbian and African art. 


In 1947 he was appointed to the staff at Canterbury University College School of Art. Although criticised for his eclecticism, Clark’s association with 'The Group' and his Urewera series highlight his important contribution to New Zealand’s cultural development. 



His work is represented in the collections of the Christchurch Art Gallery and the Museum of New Zealand - Te Papa Tongarewa, the Auckland Art Gallery and many other public and private collections in New Zealand."



Anyway... Today I was really angry listening to the Minster of Finance on the evening news telling us all how Learning Media has to be wound up because it can't make a profit. 


Respectfully, the important fact is that the provision of quality educational resources is not about profit Minister!

The closure of  this smallest of the State Owned Enterprises will not swing the government  books back into surplus. All it will do is open the door to more darn pedlars.  My intolerance of commercial firms 'selling' resources to schools is reaching breaking point. The vast majority of resources being sold to schools are pedagogical crap.

At our school we have the smallest budget ever for buying 'so-called' resources for one good reason. They don't make a difference to learning and achievement. As a principal I have been able to say "get lost" to so many resource sales people because I know that the free, high quality, non commercial Learning Media products will take care of that need for us.

There is no such thing as a free lunch. Free School Journals provided to schools are only free if they are authored by people who work to provide them for artistic and educational merit. If School Journal production  and editorial content is offered to commercial firms for the sake of profit things change. And can change in a sinister way.

To prove the point I have to go to the extreme. Read this article in the New York Review of Books.  
Now  consider curriculum. We have to accept that any curriculum in a state school system can never be politically neutral. The very definition of 'state curriculum' means that the government of the day sets the curricular tone. But the heritage of the NZ School Journal is all about exposing children to high quality art and writing, not a curriculum ideology. 

If content is open to profit based tenders then the resource pedlars come on in. They will pitch towards offering narrow National Standards content. Worse still, they will do so in a shallow pedagogical way. If the majority of the current resource-for-sale rubbish has a chance to get into the School Journals then heaven help us all.

The 'provider and examiner' corruption is a problem already evident overseas. In the UK, USA and Australia there is a disturbing trend. Commercial companies provide exams and assessment tools to the school system. They also helpfully also sell textbooks and resources to help kids pass the exams. So what is the role of a teacher in such a system? 

Look at the HMHCO website
They sell the assessment tools 
Teachers just have to turn up to work, use the resources provided, and get the kids to pass the tests. 

New Zealand is better than this. As a taxpayer I am happy to pay for the small cost of Learning Media to keep on being a tiny little loss-making quirky organisation. One that keeps on sending schools free resources. Resources which are artistic and creative and also grow the careers of New Zealand's budding  writers. 

If that is not possible then end it now. Stop the School Journals.  Stop them before HMHCO  (or a similar company) offers the NZ Government a good deal to publish them for us.

After digesting today's news an unscientific survey of the Clark family has support for my idea of ending it now, after 100 glorious years, rather than feeding kids a newer corporate-backed-efficient-resource from now on. 

Without the School Journal we may not have had arts and literary careers from these School Journal contributors  ...
 Margaret Mahy, Janet Frame, Elsie Locke, James K. Baxter, Witi Ihimaera, Patricia Grace, Joy Cowley, Jack Lasenby, David Hill, Norman Bilbrough; and artists, illustrators and photographers such as Don Binney, Russell Clark, Cliff Whiting, Dick Frizzell, Mervyn Taylor, Gil Hanly, Ans Westra, Gavin Bishop, 

What do you think about a 'free to schools' but profitable for someone-else School Journal future?

7 comments:

  1. The other already contracted content developers, who went through a 2 year appointment process to get on the MoE panel of providers, do all the same stuff at a fraction of the cost.

    If you want to blame anyone, look no further than the board of LML.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This govt keeps showing us, time after time, they know the price of everything, the value of nothing. Privacy, gambling, water, democracy, culture: if they're not for sale, they have no value.
    That list of remarkable NZers who got their start- and/or made a small living through working for - the School Journal is testament to the School Journal knowing and fostering talent. Quality is always hard to measure in dollars. But take it away and we're left with nothing but numbers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The visionary educators at LML churned out dozens of quirky and clever multimedia CDs that bridge the learning gap for special needs kids in schools all over NZ. The SNs at the decile 2 school I contract to are sure going to miss those CDs.

      Delete
  3. Anonymous, I found the directors here in the Learning Media Annual Report for 2012 http://www.learningmedia.co.nz/sites/default/filemanager/7470.pdf and a whole lot else about Learning Media that helped me understand why it might not make a profit. Whether it was directors, the integration of CWA New Media, or... or... or... that helped make Learning Media so unprofitable, when I just read about its miscellany of activities I thought NO WONDER WHAT A MESS. If only they'd brought on board a visionary business person or two who 'get' literature for children (like Gecko Press' Julia Marshall–I don't know her at all, but what a beautiful thing she's done with children's books). Preferably with e-book experience.

    Instead, our children's education may now be compromised (if not already compromised) by whoever pretends to 'do all the same stuff at a fraction of the cost'. I've seen some truly dreadful 'same stuff', developed for entirely commercial reasons. And suspect that the MoE two-year appointment process was as subject to lobbying etc as all other government provider appointments. Maybe that's OK for roads. But not for our children.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Santa Monica Canada Migration program is a highly reputed migration program for students in India. Students who apply with Santa Monica Canada Migration program are fully supported by Immigration Attorney with over 20 years experience and in depth, updated knowledge of all immigration and visa rules and its amendments at Canada Immigration Department. In Santa Monica Canada Migration program, expert academicians will assist you to select and pursue the desired program at any of the well reputed colleges and universities in Canada. Thus Santa Monica Canada Migration program helps students to pursue their dream of higher studies in one of the safest countries in the world, Canada.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A few best selling replica watches are provided here for intended purchasers who want to get a high quality and inexpensive watch. Jacob & Co Epic II Those who have a special nose for limited edition watch models may go for rolex watch which runs on premium Swiss movement. Replica watches satisfies the desire of all those who aspire for a branded watch. Rolex watch is one the best selling replica watch models. Technomarine BlackSnow These replica watches come with attractive colors and useful functions.Richard Mille RM2009 Replica watches are suitable for both formal as well as casual occasions. Rolex watch is the best website for high quality Swiss replica watches. Certina C-Sport All our watches are 1:1 mirror replicas of the original watches. They will look, feel, and work exactly as the originals.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Take a juicy our of life with the most admirable Replica Lv Handbags from our online shop, Louis Vuitton Damier Geant we are always dedicated to satisfy all your fashion needs by providing the most affordable bags and professional customer service. Stylish, Messenger bags colorful and functional, Replica gucci handbags are the perfect handbags for you to store everyday essentials and wants while help you flaunt everyday style! Take a juicy our of life with the most admirable handbags from our online shop, Messenger bags we are always dedicated to satisfy all your fashion needs by providing the most affordable bags and professional customer service.

    ReplyDelete